The Pros and Cons of Renovating vs. Building a Custom Home

Published June 25, 2023

Deciding between renovating an existing property or building a custom home from scratch can be a challenging decision. Both options come with their own set of advantages and considerations that need to be weighed carefully. Let’s explore the factors you should consider when choosing between renovating and choosing a custom home to help you make the best choice for your unique situation.

Renovating an Existing Property:

  • Cost: Renovating an existing property is generally more cost-effective than building a custom home. You already have the basic structure in place, so you can focus on updating and modifying the existing features. However, unforeseen issues or the need for extensive repairs can increase the overall cost.
  • Location: If you love your current neighborhood and its amenities, renovating allows you to stay in the same location. This is especially beneficial if you have established connections, schools, or a community that you are deeply connected to.
  • Time: Renovations typically take less time to complete compared to building a custom home. With the right planning and a reliable contractor, you can minimize the disruption to your daily life and move back into your updated home sooner.
  • Character: Older properties often possess unique charm and character that cannot be replicated. By renovating, you can preserve the architectural details and historical significance of the property while adding modern amenities to enhance livability.
  • Limitations: Renovations come with certain limitations, as you must work within the existing structure. There may be constraints regarding layout changes, structural modifications, or outdated infrastructure that could impact your desired vision.

Building a Custom Home:

  • Personalization: Building a custom home offers you the freedom to design and personalize every aspect of your new dwelling. From the layout and room sizes to the finishes and fixtures, you have complete control over the aesthetics and functionality of your dream home.
  • Efficiency: New homes are built to meet the latest energy efficiency standards, which can result in long-term savings on utility bills. You can incorporate green features, advanced insulation, and sustainable materials, reducing your carbon footprint and increasing the overall efficiency of your home.
  • Modern Amenities: Custom home building allows you to integrate the latest technology and amenities into your living space. From smart home systems and energy-efficient appliances to home theaters and custom-designed spaces, you can create a home that caters to your specific needs and lifestyle.
  • No Compromises: Unlike renovations, building from scratch eliminates the need for compromise. You won’t have to work around existing limitations or adapt to someone else’s design choices. Instead, you can create a home that perfectly aligns with your preferences and requirements.
  • Cost and Time Considerations: Building a custom home can often be more expensive and time-consuming compared to renovating. You will need to factor in the cost of land, architectural plans, permits, and construction. Additionally, the process of designing and building a home from scratch can take several months or even years to complete.

While remodeling can be a suitable option for those who appreciate the charm of an existing structure, building a new home offers unparalleled customization, modern features, reduced maintenance costs, and the opportunity to create a space that grows with you. Ultimately, the best choice between renovating and custom home building depends on you. Whether you choose to renovate or build a custom home, the end goal is to create a space that truly feels like home.

Ready to take the next steps? Call us today and let the LaFollette team help answer any questions you may have. With us as your partner, you can begin the custom home-building process with confidence! Give us a call at 979-822-6055 or contact us at for a consultation.



More Posts

Your dream home is only a phone call away

When you are ready for a builder who understands your family’s dreams and desires, talk to our family at LaFollette Custom Homes. Our team of Custom Home Consultants will guide you through the process from start to finish.